This was apparently the Clark-Reesor house. A City of Toronto document says the fire happened in August of 2006. The house was torn down before May 2012, according to street view footage from Google Maps. RIP house.
This house looks to be long gone. I could hardly see where it stood when I visited there today.
Yikes -- does the blackened interior still smell "burnt"?
This house is listed on a property owned by James Clark on the Canadian County Atlas.
It was already abandoned last summer when I came across it. :(